Viewing the failed float in the context of Australia’s underage social media ban, and what it all means for Australia’s turn against Big Tech.

Hell hath no fury like a tech bro scorned.

Following the collapse of what was to be Australia’s second-largest IPO, Firmus co-founder Oliver Curtis lashed out at the lucky country, whose “dim views” had meant we’d “missed an opportunity for Australia.”

But rather than a missed opportunity, this failed IPO shows Australia once again at the forefront of a global pushback against Big Tech and its growth-at-all-costs mindset.

The story starts in late 2024, when Australia became the first country to ban under-16s from social media. That history explains what happened to Firmus, and what might follow.

Past tense: the social media ban is … working?

The tech giants told us that age verification was impossible to implement. Meta said the proposed legislation “overlooked the practical realities of age assurance technology”, TikTok called it “unworkable”, and YouTube argued enforcement difficulties would mean it could “not fulfill its promise of making kids safer online”.

Strange that Silicon Valley came out swinging against a precedent that threatened the estimated US$11bn in annual ad revenue it earns from American minors.

Despite their protests, the law took effect in December 2025 and within a month 4.7 million accounts held by Australian children had been restricted: results the eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant called “very pleasing”.

Critics rightly note that many underage accounts remain active, but this is generational change that was never going to be 100% effective. Seatbelts don’t save every life; that doesn’t mean we should stop wearing them.

That argument also misses the bigger picture. Ripping kids away from screens designed to capture their attention was the first win; the bigger one is that other countries are following us. This was a rare instance of a sovereign nation – our sovereign nation – standing up to the lightly regulated tech giants and putting our children’s safety over their profits.

Brazil was the first follower, with a law requiring under-16 accounts to be linked to a parent’s. Indonesia barred under-16s from high-risk platforms, and Malaysia introduced government reviewed age verification checks. France’s social media ban for under-15s passed the Senate by a vote of 243 to two, the sort of French dominance normally reserved for PSG, while Türkiye’s ban followed a mass shooting by a 14-year-old boy that killed nine people and ushered in a debate on youth radicalisation and online content. Meanwhile Britain, Denmark, Greece, Spain and the UAE have announced or are planning social media bans of their own. The US, true to form, has left it to the courts: a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay US$942m after finding its platforms a “public nuisance”.

Global leadership on these complex issues is often hard to quantify, but this is what it looks like. Australia did something, and the rest of the world followed.

What’s most interesting is what we did next.

Present tense: investors say no

The social media ban was government drawing a line. With Firmus, the line came from investors and the financial press.

Much has been written about Firmus’s failure to launch, but the more interesting story is that the Australian finance sector and media collectively challenged the AI hype, scrutinising, rather than accepting, Firmus’s claims.

My favourite line came from an ABC article in September, which noted that “an important caveat for many of the figures being touted in the financial press for Firmus’s float is that they are based on conjecture and hype.”

That does seem like an important caveat.

Investors were just as sceptical. Plato Investment Management’s portfolio manager David Allen said Firmus’s “valuation prices in five years of flawless execution from a loss-making business with barely a track record.” These voices were highlighted by a financial press that refused to accept marketing collateral as fact, instead challenging a rapidly inflating valuation seemingly based on very little.

AI critic Ed Zitron called “the Australian media’s coverage of Firmus an embarrassment to the American finance and tech press.” By pushing back against Firmus’s claims and metrics and scrutinising the banks backing the float, the press voiced the public’s concerns about AI data centres, and the technologies they enable.

This scrutiny might seem obvious in hindsight, but these raises have not always played out this way. Nasdaq-listed CoreWeave and IREN, both crypto miners turned AI data centre operators, have found willing investors on similarly shaky fundamentals. Firmus has been rumoured to list on the Nasdaq after its ASX nightmare, seeing the US as a friendlier home than Aussies and their “dim views”.

These core issues of questionable timelines, revenue concentration and unsustainable debt are common to all neoclouds. In the US, backing from Nvidia and Blackstone has been enough to carry the hype. Firmus had the same backers, and in Australia that was not enough.

How Lambda, the next Nvidia-backed neocloud set to IPO in the US, fares will be the test.

Will Australians, this time our press and institutional investors, lead the way again?

Future tense: what comes next?

This unlikely union between government, media and the finance sector, backed by the public, puts Australia’s children and super ahead of the hypescalers’ never-ending quest for growth.

A government that has already taken on the social media giants, facing an industry whose biggest local float just collapsed, has little reason to hold back.

The politics support action. YouGov polling for the Climate Council in July found 67% of Australians worry data centres will raise power bills, while a survey by Primara Research found 83% of us wouldn’t want to live near a data centre.

In a rare act of bipartisanship, both Anthony Albanese and Angus Taylor support stronger copyright protection for Australian creatives from AI labs that train models on their work. Sources in both parties have shared that the leaders are eager to come together on a solution that would compensate creative rights-holders without forcing OpenAI and Anthropic to sign individual licence agreements, creating an unwanted global precedent for the Frontier Labs.

This would be another global first; another sign that Australia will stand up to Silicon Valley.

If our combined political leadership, institutional investors, journalists and broader public remain united in their refusal to accept the promise of a digital utopia, what does that mean for the future? The regulatory and societal conditions needed to realise a digital utopia are drastically different to those focused on protecting Australians from threats to children, privacy breaches, addiction, hacking and the fallout should the two most unprofitable companies in the history of capitalism stumble.

How technology growth collides with a strained grid, geopolitical tensions and public backlash will determine who prospers and who withers.

At BWD, we spend more time than we should thinking about these things (I’m sure my wife would rather talk about something like “our children” instead of Anthropic’s leaked prospectus).

We work with clients across the economy to understand how these risks and opportunities intersect and what a durable strategy looks like. What does our world look like if Australia continues to play a leading role pushing back on the might of Silicon Valley?

For any business that builds, buys or depends on AI, the answer will shape its power costs and its licence to operate. If that question is on your board’s agenda, talk to us.

We’d love to hear your thoughts – email ian.lieblich@bwdstrategic.com or message him on LinkedIn if you’d like to continue the conversation.

About the Author

Ian Lieblich is a Senior Strategy Manager at sustainability strategy consultancy BWD Strategic, with over a decade of climate and energy policy experience.